Showing posts with label open letter. Show all posts
Showing posts with label open letter. Show all posts

Monday, 23 December 2013

President Goodluck Jonathan reply Obasanjo's letter

December 20th 2013

His Excellency,
Chief Olusegun Obasanjo, GCFR
Agbe L’Oba House, Quarry Road,
Ibara, Abeokuta.

RE: BEFORE IT IS TOO LATE

I wish to formally acknowledge
your letter dated December 2, 2013
and other previous correspondence
similar to it.
You will recall that all the letters
were brought to me by hand.
Although both of us discussed
some of the issues in those letters, I
had not, before now, seen the need
for any formal reply since, to me,
they contained advice from a
former President to a serving
President. Obviously, you felt
differently because in your last
letter, you complained about my
not acknowledging or replying your
previous letters.

It is with the greatest possible
reluctance that I now write this
reply. I am most uneasy about
embarking on this unprecedented
and unconventional form of open
communication between me and a
former leader of our country
because I know that there are more
acceptable and dignified means of
doing so.

But I feel obliged to reply your letter
for a number of reasons: one, you
formally requested for a reply and
not sending you one will be
interpreted as ignoring a former
President.

Secondly, Nigerians know the role
you have played in my political life
and given the unfortunate tone of
your letter, clearly, the grapes have
gone sour. Therefore, my side of the
story also needs to be told.

The third reason why I must reply
you in writing is that your letter is
clearly a threat to national security
as it may deliberately or
inadvertently set the stage for
subversion.

The fourth reason for this reply is
that you raised very weighty issues,
and since the letter has been made
public, Nigerians are expressing
legitimate concerns. A response
from me therefore, becomes very
necessary.

The fifth reason is that this letter
may appear in biographies and
other books which political
commentators on Nigeria’s
contemporary politics may write. It
is only proper for such publications
to include my comments on the
issues raised in your letter.

Sixthly, you are very unique in
terms of the governance of this
country. You were a military Head
of State for three years and eight
months, and an elected President
for eight years. That means you
have been the Head of Government
of Nigeria for about twelve years.
This must have, presumably,
exposed you to a lot of information.
Thus when you make a statement,
there is the tendency for people to
take it seriously.

The seventh reason is that the
timing of your letter coincided with
other vicious releases. The Speaker
of the House of Representatives
spoke of my “body language”
encouraging corruption. A letter
written to me by the CBN Governor
alleging that NNPC, within a period
of 19 months did not remit the sum
of USD49.8 billion to the federation
account, was also deliberately
leaked to the public.

The eighth reason is that it appears
that your letter was designed to
incite Nigerians from other
geopolitical zones against me and
also calculated to promote ethnic
disharmony. Worse still, your letter
was designed to instigate members
of our Party, the PDP, against me.

The ninth reason is that your letter
conveys to me the feeling that
landmines have been laid for me.
Therefore, Nigerians need to have
my response to the issues raised
before the mines explode.

The tenth and final reason why my
reply is inevitable is that you have
written similar letters and made
public comments in reference to all
former Presidents and Heads of
Government starting from Alhaji
Shehu Shagari and these have
instigated different actions and
reactions. The purpose and
direction of your letter is distinctly
ominous, and before it is too late,
my clarifications on the issues need
to be placed on record.

Let me now comment on the issues
you raised. In commenting I wish to
crave your indulgence to compare
what is happening now to what
took place before. This, I believe,
will enable Nigerians see things in
better perspective because we must
know where we are coming from so
as to appreciate where we now are,
and to allow us clearly map out
where we are going.

You raised concerns about the
security situation in the country. I
assure you that I am fully aware of
the responsibility of government for
ensuring the security of the lives
and property of citizens. My
Administration is working
assiduously to overcome current
national security challenges, the
seeds of which were sown under
previous administrations. There
have been some setbacks; but
certainly there have also been great
successes in our efforts to
overcome terrorism and
insurgency.

Those who continue to down-play
our successes in this regard,
amongst whom you must now be
numbered, appear to have
conveniently forgotten the depths to
which security in our country had
plunged before now.

At a stage, almost the entire North-
East of Nigeria was under siege by
insurgents. Bombings of churches
and public buildings in the North
and the federal capital became an
almost weekly occurrence. Our
entire national security apparatus
seemed nonplussed and unable to
come to grips with the new threat
posed by the berthing of terrorism
on our shores.

But my administration has since
brought that very unacceptable
situation under significant control.
We have overhauled our entire
national security architecture,
improved intelligence gathering,
training, funding, logistical support
to our armed forces and security
agencies, and security collaboration
with friendly countries with very
visible and positive results.

The scope and impact of terrorist
operations have been significantly
reduced and efforts are underway
to restore full normalcy to the most
affected North Eastern region and
initiate a post-crisis development
agenda, including a special
intervention programme to boost
the region’s socio-economic
progress.

In doing all this, we have kept our
doors open for dialogue with the
insurgents and their supporters
through efforts such as the work of
the Presidential Committee on
Dialogue and the Peaceful
Resolution of the Security
Challenges in the North-East. You
also know that the Governor of
Borno State provided the items you
mentioned to me as carrots. Having
done all this and more, it is
interesting that you still accuse me
of not acting on your hardly original
recommendation that the carrot
and stick option be deployed to
solve the Boko Haram problem.

Your suggestion that we are
pursuing a “war against violence
without understanding the root
causes of the violence and applying
solutions to deal with all the
underlying factors” is definitely
misplaced because from the onset
of this administration, we have
been implementing a multifaceted
strategy against militancy,
insurgency and terrorism that
includes poverty alleviation,
economic development, education
and social reforms.

Even though basic education is the
constitutional responsibility of
States, my administration has, as
part of its efforts to address
ignorance and poor education
which have been identified as two
of the factors responsible for
making some of our youth easily
available for use as cannon fodder
by insurgents and terrorists,
committed huge funds to the
provision of modern basic
education schools for the Almajiri
in several Northern States. The
Federal Government under my
leadership has also set up nine
additional universities in the
Northern States and three in the
Southern States in keeping with my
belief that proper education is the
surest way of emancipating and
empowering our people.

More uncharitable persons may
even see a touch of
sanctimoniousness in your new
belief in the carrot and stick
approach to overcoming militancy
and insurgency. You have always
referred to how you hit Odi in
Bayelsa State to curb militancy in
the Niger Delta. If the invasion of
Odi by the Army was the stick, I did
not see the corresponding carrot. I
was the Deputy Governor of
Bayelsa State then, and as I have
always told you, the invasion of Odi
did not solve any militancy problem
but, to some extent, escalated it. If
it had solved it, late President
Yar’Adua would not have had to
come up with the amnesty
program. And while some elements
of the problem may still be there, in
general, the situation is reasonably
better.

In terms of general insecurity in the
country and particularly the crisis
in the Niger Delta, 2007 was one of
the worst periods in our history.
You will recall three incidents that
happened in 2007 which seemed to
have been orchestrated to achieve
sinister objectives. Here in Abuja, a
petrol tanker loaded with explosives
was to be rammed into the INEC
building. But luckily for the country,
an electric pole stopped the tanker
from hitting the INEC building. It is
clear that this incident was meant
to exploit the general sense of
insecurity in the nation at the time
to achieve the aim of stopping the
2007 elections. It is instructive that
you, on a number of occasions,
alluded to this fact.

When that incident failed, an armed
group invaded Yenagoa one
evening with the intent to
assassinate me. Luckily for me,
they could not. They again attacked
and bombed my country home on a
night when I was expected in the
village. Fortunately, as God would
have it, I did not make the trip.
I recall that immediately after both
incidents, I got calls expressing the
concern of Abuja. But Baba, you
know that despite the apparent
concern of Abuja, no single arrest
was ever made. I was then the
Governor of Bayelsa State and the
PDP Vice-Presidential candidate.

The security people ordinarily
should have unraveled the
assassination attempt on me.
You also raised the issues of
kidnapping, piracy and armed
robbery. These are issues all
Nigerians, including me are very
concerned about. While we will
continue to do our utmost best to
reduce all forms of criminality to
the barest minimum in our country,
it is just as well to remind you that
the first major case of kidnapping
for ransom took place around
2006. And the Boko Haram crisis
dates back to 2002. Goodluck
Jonathan was not the President of
the country then. Also, armed
robbery started in this country
immediately after the civil war and
since then, it has been a problem to
all succeeding governments. For a
former Head of Government, who
should know better, to present
these problems as if they were
creations of the Jonathan
Administration is most
uncharitable.

Having said that, let me remind you
of some of the things we have done
to curb violent crime in the country.
We have reorganized the Nigerian
Police Force and appointed a more
dynamic leadership to oversee its
affairs. We have also improved its
manpower levels as well as
funding, training and logistical
support.

We have also increased the
surveillance capabilities of the
Police and provided its air-wing
with thrice the number of
helicopters it had before the
inception of the present
administration. The National Civil
Defence and Security Corps has
been armed to make it a much
more effective ally of the police and
other security agencies in the war
against violent crime. At both
domestic and international levels,
we are doing everything possible to
curb the proliferation of the small
arms and light weapons with which
armed robberies, kidnappings and
piracy are perpetrated. We have
also enhanced security at our
borders to curb cross-border
crimes.

We are aggressively addressing the
challenge of crude oil theft in
collaboration with the state
Governors. In addition, the Federal
Government has engaged the
British and US governments for
their support in the tracking of the
proceeds from the purchase of
stolen crude. Similarly, a regional
Gulf of Guinea security strategy has
been initiated to curb crude oil theft
and piracy.

Perhaps the most invidious
accusation in your letter is the
allegation that I have placed over
one thousand Nigerians on a
political watch list, and that I am
training snipers and other militia to
assassinate people. Baba, I don’t
know where you got that from but
you do me grave injustice in not
only lending credence to such
baseless rumours, but also
publicizing it. You mentioned God
seventeen times in your letter. Can
you as a Christian hold the Bible
and say that you truly believe this
allegation?





Wednesday, 18 December 2013

Irabo Obasanjo's letter to her father


It brings me no joy to have to write this
but since you started this trend of open
letters I thought I would follow suit
since you don’t listen to anyone
anyway. The only way to reach you
may be to make the public aware of
some things. As a child well brought
up by my long-suffering mother in
Yoruba tradition, I have been reluctant
to tell the truth about you but as it
seems you still continue to delude
yourself about the kind of person you
are and I think for posterity’s sake it is
time to set the records straight.

I will return to the issue of my long-
suffering mother later in this letter.
Like most Nigerians, I believe there are
very enormous issues currently
plaguing the country but I was surely
surprised that you will be the one to
publish such a treatise. I remember
clearly as if it was yesterday the day I
came over to Abuja from Abeokuta
when I was Commissioner of Health in
OgunState, specifically to ask you not
to continue to pursue the third term
issue.
I had tried to bring it up when your
sycophantic aides were present and
they brushed my comments aside and
as usual you listened to their self-
serving counsel. For you to accuse
someone else of what you so obviously
practiced yourself tells of your
narcissistic megalomaniac personality.

Everyone around for even a few
minutes knows that the only thing you
respond to is praise and worship of
you. People have learnt how to
manipulate you by giving you what
you crave. The only ones that can’t
and will not stroke your ego are family
members who you universally treat like
poo (sic) apart from the few who have
learned to manipulate you like others.

Before I continue, Nigerians are people
who see conspiracy and self-service in
everything because I think they believe
everyone is like them. This letter is not
in support of President Jonathan or
APC or any other group or person, but
an outpouring from my soul to God. I
don’t blame you for the many
atrocities you have been able to get
away with, Nigerians were your
enablers every step of the way.

People
ultimately get leaders that reflect them.
Getting back to the story, I made sure
your aides were not around and
brought up the issue, trying to deliver
the presentation of the issue as I had
practiced it in my head. I started with
the fact that we copied the US
constitution which has term limits of
two terms for a President. As is your
usual manner, you didn’t allow me to
finish my thought process and listen to
my point of view. Once I broached the
subject you sat up and said that the
US had no term limits in the past but
that it had been introduced in the
1940s after the death of President
Roosevelt, which is true.

I wanted to say to you: when you copy
something you also copy the
modifications based on the learning
from the original; only a fool starts
from scratch and does not base his
decisions on the learning of others. In
science, we use the modifications
found by others long ago to the most
recent, as the basis of new findings;
not going back to discover and learn
what others have learnt. Human
knowledge and development and
civilization will not have progressed if
each new generation and society did
not build on the knowledge of others
before them.

The American constitution itself is
based on several theories and
philosophies of governance available
in the 18th century. Democracy itself is
a governance method started by the
ancient Greeks. America’s founding
fathers used it with modifications
based on what hadn’t worked well for
the ancient Greeks and on new
theories since then.
As usual in our conversations, I kept
quiet because I know you well. You
weren’t going to change your mind
based on my intervention as you had
already made up your mind on the
persuasion of the minions working for
you who were ripping the country
blind. When I spoke to you, your
outward attitude to the people of the
country was that you were not
interested in the third term and that it
was others pushing it. Your statement
to me that day proved to me that you
were the brain behind the third term
debacle. It is therefore outrageous that
you accuse the current President of a
similar two-facedness that you
yourself used against the people of the
country.

I was on a plane trip between Abuja
and Lagos around the time of the third
term issue and I sat next to one of
your sycophants on the plane. He told
me: “Only Obasanjo can rule Nigeria”.
I replied: “God has not created a
country where only one person can
rule. If only one person can rule
Nigeria then the whole Nigeria project
is not a viable one, as it will be a non-
sustainable project”
I don’t know how you came about
Yar’Adua as the candidate for your
party as it was not my priority or job.
Unlike you, I focus on the issues I have
been given responsibility over and not
on the jobs of others. It was the day of
the PDP Presidential Campaign in
Abeokuta during the state-by-state
tour of 2007 that Yar’Adua got sick
and had to be flown abroad. The MKO
Abiola Stadium was already filled with
people by 9am when I drove by (and)
we had told people based on the
campaign schedule that the rally would
start at noon.

At 11 am I headed for the stadium on
foot; it was a short walk as there were
so many cars already parked in and
out. As I walked on with two other
people, we saw crowds of people
leaving the stadium. I recognized some
of them as politicians and I asked
them why people were leaving. They
said the Presidential candidate had
died. I was alarmed and shocked. I
walked back home and received a call
from a friend in Lagos who said the
same and added that he had died in
the plane carrying him abroad for
treatment and that the plane was on
its way to Katsina to bury him.
I called you, and told you the
information and that the stadium was
already half-empty. You told me to go
to the stadium and tell the people on
the podium to announce that the
Presidential candidate had taken ill
that morning but the rest of the team,
including you and the Vice-Presidential
candidate would arrive shortly. I did as
I was told, but even the people on the
podium at first didn’t make the
announcement because they thought it
was true that Yar’Adua had died. I had
to take the microphone and make the
announcement myself. It did little
good. People kept trooping out of the
stadium. Your team didn’t arrive until
4pm and by this time we had just a
sprinkling of people left.

That evening after the disaster of a
rally, you said you had insisted that
the Presidential candidate fly to
Germany for a check-up although you
said he only had a cold. I asked why
would anyone fly to Germany to treat a
cold? And you said “I would rather die
than have the man die at this time.” I
thought of this profound statement as
things later unfolded against me.

Then
I thought it a silly statement but as
usual I kept quiet, little did I know how
your machinations for a person would
be used against me. When Yar’Adua
eventually died, you stayed alive, I
would have expected you to jump into
his grave.

I left Nigeria in 1989 right after youth
service to study in the US and I visited
in 1994 for a week and didn’t visit
again until your inauguration in 1999.
In between, you had been arrested by
Abacha and jailed. We, your children,
had no one who stood with us. Stella
famously went around collecting
money on your behalf but we had no
one. We survived. I was the only one of
the children working then as a post-
doctoral fellow when I got the call
from a friend informing me of your
arrest.

A week before your arrest, you had
called me from Denmark and I had
told you that you should be careful
that the government was very offended
by some of your statements and
actions and may be planning to arrest
or kill you as was occurring to many at
the time. The source of my information
was my mother who, agitated, had
called me, saying I should warn you as
this was the rumour in the country.

As
usual you brushed aside my
comments, shouting on the phone that
they cannot try anything and you will
do and say as you please. The
consequence of your bravado is
history.
We, your family, have borne the brunt
of your direct cruelty and also suffered
the consequences of your stupidity but
got none of the benefits of your
successes. Of course, anyone around
you knows how little respect you have
for your children.

You think our existence on earth is
about you. By the way, how many are
we? 19, 20, 21? Do you even know? In
the last five years, how many of these
children have you spoken to? How
many grandchildren do you have and
when did you last see each of them?
As President you would listen to advice
of people that never finished high
school who would say anything to
keep having access to you so as to
make money over your children who
loved you and genuinely wished you
well.

At your first inauguration in 1999, I
and my brothers and sisters told you
we were coming from the US. As is
usual with you, you made no
arrangements for our trip, instead our
mom organized to meet each of us
and provided accommodation. At the
actual swearing-in at Eagle Square,
the others decided to watch it on TV.
Instead I went to the square and I was
pushed and tossed by the crowd.
I managed to get in front of the crowd
where I waved and shouted at you as
you and General Abdulsalam
Abubakar walked past to go back to
the VIP seating area. I saw you mouth
‘my daughter’ to General Abdullahi
who was the one who pulled me out of
the crowd and gave me a seat. As I
looked around I saw Stella and Stella’s
family prominently seated but none of
your children. I am sure General
Abdullahi would remember this
incident and I am eternally grateful to
him.